
Adobe's $9.86bn Prime Tally Belongs to the Calendar
Adobe's $9.86bn for Amazon's October Prime Big Deal Days counts every US online retailer's two days, and it grew at about the pace of the month around it. Numerator, which can see Amazon, finds a real lift, but the best sellers were protein shakes, wipes and toilet paper, and Adobe's one strong clothing line was basics. Market-wide markdowns peaked at a fifth off, while Amazon and Target advertised up to 50% off selected clothing.
Neritus Vale
Adobe’s $9.86bn is what all US online retailers sold between them on Tuesday 6 and Wednesday 7 October, and the trade press has attributed it to Amazon’s Prime Big Deal Days. The total was 8.5% above last year’s event. Retail Dive reported that the sale “helped drive” it, and Digital Commerce 360’s headline said the event “drove” it. The figure measures the calendar: two days of everyone’s online sales, including what two ordinary days would have brought in and what rivals sold at matching prices. On Numerator’s panel, Amazon’s own shoppers did lift their spending, but the best sellers were household staples.
Adobe’s own 28 September forecast called the event “an industrywide e-commerce moment, with discounts happening broadly across U.S. retailers.” Target’s Circle Deal Days took the same two days, and Walmart’s competing sale ran until 11 October. In June, Adobe said its data profiles “retail broadly, rather than any individual retailer.” A total built that way rises when Amazon sells more, and just as readily when Walmart does.
The two days grew at about the pace of the month around them. Adobe’s forecast has October’s online spending up 8%, and the event came in below the same forecast’s estimate for it. Last year Adobe said October’s growth was “propelled by Prime Day event,” though the event grew more slowly than the month. If this October lands where Adobe expects, the event’s share of the month will be about a tenth, as it was last year.
Most of the headline is what two ordinary days would have brought in anyway. Rack & Reason’s arithmetic on Adobe’s October forecast puts an average pair of the month’s other 29 days at $5.93bn. That leaves roughly $3.93bn as the event’s margin over the calendar, and rivals’ matching sales sit inside it too.
Numerator, whose panel covers more than 1 million US households, can see Amazon’s own pull, and it is real. Household spending on Amazon “nearly doubled compared with an average Tuesday and Wednesday,” Numerator said in early results carried by Supermarket News, “four times the lift Walmart recorded during the first two days of its sale.”
Set against the market, Amazon’s lift looks larger, though the baselines differ. By our arithmetic, $9.86bn is 66% above that $5.93bn average pair. Numerator’s baseline is an average Tuesday and Wednesday of Amazon spend in its panel; ours is a forecast monthly average across all retailers, Walmart’s sale days included. Amazon drew a bigger lift than the market it is credited with, but the two figures are not like for like.
Amazon’s best sellers by units looked like a weekly shop. Numerator’s tracker named Premier Protein shakes, Lysol disinfecting wipes, Scott toilet paper and Dawn dish spray among them, and 68% of items sold for under $20. Modern Retail wrote this week that the event has turned October into “the official kickoff for holiday shopping.” Stocking up was one use of the event, not the whole of it: Supermarket News reported that 22% of low-income and 27% of high-income households stocked up.
Numerator does claim a pull on the holidays, but its sentence names no base. Its early results say “more than a third of shoppers” finished at least half of their holiday shopping during the event. Its tracker puts gift buyers at one in five, and 18% of them completed more than half of their gift shopping. On those numbers, holiday gifting was a minority use of the event.
Consumer prices explain little of the growth on the Bureau’s measure. Goods other than food and energy cost 0.7% more in August than a year earlier, the latest month the Bureau of Labor Statistics has published. Headline inflation leans on energy and services, which online shops sell little of.
Inflation shows up in what shoppers say, not in prices: 74% told Numerator it influenced their decision to shop.
Most of Adobe’s other reported percentages are not year-on-year growth. “The share of the most expensive goods increased by 21%” against the year-to-date average, which describes the mix of what sold rather than how much. Digital Commerce 360’s category gains compare the two days with average September sales, which is why costumes rose 610% with Halloween more than three weeks away. Gift categories sit near the top of the same list: toys, electronics and video games rose between 85% and 158%.
Apparel appears in the data mainly as basics. Numerator ranked apparel among the three most commonly purchased categories on Amazon. The one clothing line among Adobe’s strong categories was “apparel basics,” up 25%, listed with household cleaning, hygiene and pet food. Amazon’s own deal page pushed “fall wardrobe staples” from its Amazon Essentials label: joggers, fleece sweatshirts, denim and layering basics. Retail Dive reported that apparel promotions “led many shoppers to trade up to higher-ticket items.”
For clothing, the bigger week is still ahead. Across all categories, October’s markdowns topped out at 20% off listed price, and Adobe’s forecast saves the season’s deepest apparel discounts for Black Friday. It expects clothing basics to jump 210% over average September sales during Cyber Week.
The strongest objection is that the whole market’s two days are Amazon’s doing. Target ran its sale on the same two dates and Walmart’s overlapped, so rivals were answering Amazon’s calendar. Adobe’s forecast itself describes the event as producing “an additional pre-season spike,” and on that reading crediting Amazon with the full $9.86bn is fair shorthand. For that to hold, the event has to add spending the season would not otherwise have had, rather than move it.
The evidence is consistent with the event moving spending. On Adobe’s forecast the event’s share of its month is flat, which fits new spending that grows in step with the month just as well. The only direct evidence is on intent: Black Friday and Cyber Monday shopping intent fell four and five points on last year’s event, and Numerator concluded that “earlier holiday shopping could put pressure on November sales events.” Credit Amazon with the whole occasion and part of the $9.86bn still looks like November spending arriving early.
A clothing brand deciding whether to match Amazon’s two days faces a price the $9.86bn cannot name. Matching buys a share of two days the whole market splits, weeks before the bigger sale, at markdowns that peaked at 20% across the market and ran higher on selected clothing: Amazon advertised up to 50% off Zappos styles, and Target offered 40% off select clothing. The alternative is to leave the joggers to Amazon Essentials. The total counted everyone’s Tuesday, so it cannot say which costs more. The brand’s own sales against an ordinary Tuesday can.