
Amazon Chooses Which Shopper Keeps the Jumper, and the Seller Pays for It
Amazon's FBA Returnless Resolutions, available in five European stores since 27 October, lets sellers set a price cap between €1 and €75 while Amazon picks which shoppers keep the goods. The one fee its announcement waives is a fee clothing does not pay in Europe.
Sir John Crabstone
Amazon’s Seller Central announcement of 27 October says FBA Returnless Resolutions “is now available” in its German, French, Italian, Spanish and UK stores. Sellers who enrol pick the ASINs and a price ceiling between €1 and €75, or £1 and £75 in the UK. Amazon then decides which shoppers get their money back and keep the goods; the seller loses the item each time.
Ecommerce News Europe, reporting the launch on 29 October, lists what Amazon weighs: the product’s price, the category, the seller’s account status and the customer’s return history. It adds that sellers worry about Amazon deciding which individual returns qualify. The seller sets the ceiling; Amazon holds the rest.
Amazon’s help page gives the customer test as “No history of program abuse”, the only customer criterion it prints. Amazon makes each offer “on your behalf”, to customers the seller cannot vet. Shoppers are not told which items qualify, and there are “currently no downloadable reports”, only a status column on the returns page. The ceiling comes pre-set at €10. Even the seller’s good standing is “determined at Amazon’s discretion”.
The seller caps the price of each gift; Amazon chooses the recipients.
The announcement sets out the bill in a single note. Kept items earn no inventory reimbursement and still count toward the seller’s return rate. “However, the high return rate fee isn’t charged for returns resolved this way.”
Clothing does not pay that fee in Europe. Amazon’s fee page charges it on high-return-rate products in every FBA category except Clothing and Accessories, and Footwear. Those categories pay a returns processing fee instead: half the fulfilment fee, on every unit returned with free shipping. The page does not say whether a kept item counts as returned, so for a jumper the one concession may concede nothing.
Clothing is not excluded from the scheme. Amazon’s help page lists no programme fees and says enrolment saves “the fees associated with high return rates, customer returns processing, storage, and removals”. It adds that the scheme is “most cost-effective when return shipping and processing costs exceed the item’s value”. For a jumper that would have come back fit to sell, the fee at stake is half a fulfilment fee. The cost is the jumper.
Germany’s trade press has framed the scheme as the seller’s arithmetic; etailment, relaying Haendlerbund, noted that control stays with the merchant while Amazon checks each return. The merchant does control the ceiling. The arithmetic turns on a figure no merchant holds: which of its customers Amazon will let keep the goods.
One seller’s reply to Amazon’s German announcement summed it up as saving money by voluntarily giving fees to Amazon and products to buyers, while still damaging the return rate. That reckoning counts the fees and the goods. It does not price the choice of buyer, which Amazon reserves for itself.
Wortfilter warns that, once word of kept goods reaches deal forums, copycats may follow.
Amazon says refund requests are “constantly monitored for signs of fraud”. The seller can switch the scheme off, and the change takes effect at once. The jumpers already given away stay given.