
A Broker Dates the End of Pinduoduo's Free Shipping to a Bill Malaysia Has Not Tabled
CGS International calls Pinduoduo's free single-item shipping to Malaysia a temporary subsidy, yet its own figures put the yearly cost at about 1.6% of PDD's 2025 net profit. It expects the offer to end with an E-Commerce Bill not due before 2027, citing Pinduoduo's July closure of a Thai shipping channel, which came months after Thailand began charging duty from the first baht.
Sir John Crabstone
CGS International calls Pinduoduo’s free shipping on single items to Malaysia “a short-term marketing subsidy”. Its 21 October note on Mr DIY, quoted in The Edge’s Brokers Digest, does not expect the offer “to persist following the implementation of the E-Commerce Bill”. Temporary, then, means until Parliament acts.
On paper, the platform loses money on these parcels. Across its scenarios, CGS models a loss of RM1.53 to RM8.22 per item shipped; The Malaysian Reserve describes these as analyst estimates, not disclosed platform figures. With three items to a parcel, the average item must cost RM49 in the low-cost case and RM163 in the base case to break even.
The arithmetic is more candid than the conclusion. At its mid-case, CGS puts the subsidy at about RM950m a year, around 1.6% of PDD’s FY25 net profit, by the paper’s account.
A loss its owner can afford is a price, not a deadline.
Thailand’s precedent starts with duty. Since 1 January Thai customs has charged duty from the first baht, ending the exemption below 1,500 baht, with 7% VAT on top. Clothing and shoes pay the top rate of 30%, Thansettakij reported in December.
On 7 July, Customs director-general Panthong Loykulnanta said direct orders from abroad had fallen about 30% after the change, The Standard reported. The report gives no baseline or period.
Pinduoduo launched single-item free shipping in Thailand in March, two months into the tariff. On 16 July, about four months after launch, it stopped accepting new orders through its consolidated shipping channel (泰国集运). Its notice, reproduced by the Chinese trade site Baijing, set the hour at 22:00 Beijing time and gave no reason.
Industry voices supplied one. A column by 丰丰 for 东南亚电商观察, reposted by Baijing, said many logistics firms and sellers rejected the subsidy explanation; the cause, they said, likely lay in tighter duty collection and customs checks. Cainiao, the Alibaba-owned logistics arm, had told users its Thailand route could no longer combine orders normally, citing Thai tax policy. That is sellers’ inference, not a finding.
Malaysia already taxes these parcels, at a single rate. A 10% sales tax applies to goods worth less than RM500 bought online from abroad, and The Malaysian Reserve’s channel checks found shoppers charged it at checkout, with a 2% to 3% service fee. CGS also names stricter enforcement and changes to the treatment of low-value imports among its catalysts, so a Thai-style change is not outside its case.
Sin Chew Daily’s headline went further than the broker. Its new retail series opened on 9 November by asking whether Pinduoduo had started a retail war in Malaysia (拼多多挑起大马零售战?), and the standfirst calls the low-price offensive hard to sustain (低价攻势难续). The opening article relays CGS on two points: factory sourcing explains the prices, and PDD’s subsidy pays for the free postage. CGS, per The Malaysian Reserve, doubts the postage but allows that the factory-sourced prices could prove a lasting advantage.
Pinduoduo’s Malaysian share is small. CGS estimates its 2026 GMV at RM1.2bn to RM2.9bn, or 1.4% to 3.4% of e-commerce, The Malaysian Reserve reported. The note puts the share of retail sales below 0.4%. PDD does not disclose country figures.
As for the bill, the budget that announced it, as we noted in October, named neither the platforms covered nor a start date. CGS’s forecasts assume it takes effect in the second half of 2027, which The Malaysian Reserve calls “a research assumption”.
Tabling is now due at Parliament’s first sitting of 2027; a deputy minister says the draft is still being refined. Until then, the date for the bill’s effect exists only in a broker’s spreadsheet.