
The Budget Kept £90,000 per Platform and Left the Second-Hand Rail to the Dealer
HMRC's Budget policy paper sets Britain's £90,000 marketplace VAT threshold per platform and excludes second-hand goods, leaving the threshold's level, its operation and the second-hand rules to secondary legislation. The government's answer to new goods posing as second-hand is that used goods mostly sell for less, with guidance to follow, and the OBR rates the costing's uncertainty as high.
Sir John Crabstone
Britain’s Budget answered the question we left open on 20 October, and answered it leniently. Each marketplace will judge a seller by the sales it can see. Second-hand goods are left out too; the threshold’s level and the second-hand rules await legislation.
From October 2027, HMRC’s policy paper says, marketplaces will collect VAT for registered UK sellers, and for others above “a minimum annual sales threshold per platform of £90,000”. The rules “will not apply” to second-hand goods. Secondary legislation will set the threshold’s level and operation, and “the treatment of second-hand goods”.
John Healey’s Budget speech promised tougher requirements for marketplaces “so that sellers cannot avoid paying VAT when they sell online”. The detail published that day is more modest.
The factsheet is plain: “The £90,000 sales threshold applies separately to your annual sales on each platform where you do business.” An unregistered business under that line everywhere “will not be affected”. So a trader with £89,000 on each of four marketplaces stays outside collection only while unregistered.
The registration threshold counts a business’s taxable sales across every channel, so that trader must register, and is in scope on all four platforms.
The consultation response records that several marketplaces wanted a lower threshold or none, to stop sellers splitting sales. Eleven of the 13 business sellers responding voiced serious concerns about a lower one. The government matched £90,000 to the registration threshold and says “HMRC will continue normal compliance activity” below it. Yet the same document justifies the reform by the limits of “retrospective data and enforcement alone”, though it calls the two approaches complementary.
Below £90,000 a platform, the reform falls back on the method whose limits justified it.
The response gives two reasons for the exclusion: the margin scheme taxes a dealer’s profit, which a marketplace may not know, and VAT on the full price would hit prices and margins. It concedes “some risk that new goods could be misrepresented as second-hand”, judges it “suitably mitigated” because used goods sell for less “in the majority of cases”, and promises guidance to manage it.
The factsheet says UK businesses selling second-hand goods “already charge VAT on these sales in the normal way”. So a vintage dealer on a marketplace keeps accounting for its own VAT. That is the assumption the rest of the reform was built to stop making.
eBay UK’s general manager, Eve Williams, welcomed the protections for “businesses selling used goods” and “the decision to continue with the £90,000 VAT threshold”, in a statement ChannelX published.
The Budget’s policy costings put the yield at £165m in 2027-28 and £320m in 2028-29, then £250m to £270m a year. They do not explain the fall after the first full year. Their main uncertainties are “the share of sales on online marketplaces which are in-scope and the behavioural response”.
The Office for Budget Responsibility rates the costing’s uncertainty as high. Rules still to be made will fix the share in scope; sellers’ choices will settle the rest.