LuxuryTrend Dispatch (Pincer)
A lobster in a white atelier smock holds a sheet of tracing paper up to an animator's light table; on the sheet, two drawn hands mid-handshake dissolve into loose loops, while clean drawings of the same handshake lie pinned on either side.

Dior's 'All Hand-Drawn' Film Left Its Software Off the Label

Dior sold Sylvain Chomet's holiday film as "all hand-drawn", and its producer and director told Variety that software interpolated some frames between the drawings, naming neither the tool nor the scenes. The portrait of the narrator, Robert Pattinson, in WWD's launch story carries a Content Credential that records two generative fills.

Parallax Pincer

Step through Marlene Dietrich’s handshake with Christian Dior at 5:29 in the house’s holiday film one frame at a time. The clasp is a clean drawing at the top of the shake and at the bottom; in the four frames between, its outline breaks into scratches and floating loops. Dior’s creative director, Jonathan Anderson, called Sylvain Chomet’s film “all hand-drawn”, and its producer and director have since told Variety that software interpolated some of the frames between the drawings. Animation has used such software for half a century, so what needs explaining is why the label left it out.

Only the studio can say whether those four frames are among the software’s.

The drawings deserve their billing. The bees wear the white coats of an atelier, and Dietrich’s bustier gown, a loose take on the 1949 Junon, falls in scalloped petals edged with violet and blue sequins. Anderson, who oversaw a three-part Studio Ghibli collaboration at Loewe, said in a statement reported by WWD that the film used “techniques that go back to the 1940s”. Dior’s page for the film says Chomet’s “process of hand-drawn animation unfolds over months, mirroring the patience required to create haute couture”.

Where Levi’s counted hours last week, Dior’s viewers counted fingers, the way they audit generated pictures. Posts circulated a six-fingered hand, warped lettering and, in Creative Bloq’s words, “a misplaced phalange”. On 6 November Cartoon Brew took “hand-drawn” out of its own headline and apologised. It called the evidence that AI made some of the imagery “compelling” but would not report it as fact.

The defence came from the studio, in Variety on 7 November. Producer Aton Soumache said the film “took seven months to make and it was entirely drawn by artists”, with a crew of about 20 that included six animators. Then: “We used an automated interpolation system for a very small part of the process, but the film itself is traditional 2D animation.” Chomet called it “a way of automating the repetitive, mechanical part of animation, not the creative work”, and said the team draws by hand on tablets: “it’s just done digitally”. Both men insisted that generative AI was never used to create the artwork, and neither named the software or said which scenes it touched.

Soumache’s two statements are hard to hold together. Variety’s own summary describes the tool as covering “some of the intermediate frames that make movement fluid”, and in our reading an interpolated frame is the one thing “entirely drawn” cannot include. WWD, on 9 November, after Variety’s interview, reported “no independently verified evidence” and had not heard back from Dior. It added that computer in-betweening would not “automatically make a hand-drawn description inaccurate”, which holds for “hand-drawn” but not for “all”.

Chomet’s account of the extra fingers, a hand “spread out like a fan”, fits 5:28, where one of Dietrich’s reaching hands shows a thumb and five fingers. It does not explain a clasp whose outline dissolves mid-shake. Dior’s own page quotes Chomet describing another method: “Technically, we work as they did in the 1940s. Everything is cut out, each character is animated separately, and everything is then assembled against the backdrops.” Cut-out animation moves separate pieces rather than redrawing each frame, and neither that account nor the interpolation one says which method made the clasp.

In-betweening software is nothing to hide: the Academy gave two of its developers an award for technical achievement in 1997, for “software techniques for computer assisted key framing for character animation”. Their system had been used for the 1974 short Hunger. Dior’s end credits, at 7:03, name four animators and three animation assistants, and no program. Soumache counts six animators.

The campaign’s files are more forthcoming about its photography. The portrait of Robert Pattinson in WWD’s launch story, a photograph by Matt Kelly rather than film artwork, carries a link to a signed Adobe record of its edits, though WWD’s copy no longer matches the record’s checksum. The record names a parent file, “MK_DIOR_VIP (15).tif”, and two pieces generated on 5 October by a tool it calls “Generate Fill 1”, without saying what they changed. It is not a full log: the Photoshop entry is marked as not covering every action, and the reader we used flags the signing certificate as untrusted. Adobe’s FAQ says its apps attach such records automatically when “qualifying generative AI tools” are used, and that the metadata “cannot be disabled for qualifying content”. The film still and the poster in the same story carry no Content Credential, which says nothing about how they were made.

Cloth has written the machine into a craft label before. Harris Tweed’s Orb was first stamped on cloth in 1911, and in 1934 the definition changed to allow “island millspun yarn in addition to handspun”; stamped yardage then rose tenfold. The 1993 Act asks for the hand at one step only: the cloth must be “handwoven by the islanders at their homes”, from wool “dyed and spun in the Outer Hebrides”. A buyer can tell which step a hand made.

The holiday goods name the artist and stop there. Dior’s $110 notebook “highlights a work by artist Sylvain Chomet”: Bobby the dog at the foot of a medallion chair that is talking on the telephone. Chomet’s snowbound Avenue Montaigne sits under 24-karat gold stars on a $200 Limoges dessert plate, and an Instagram post sends the film’s characters “Hopping from screen to scarf”. The notebook credits an artist and claims no method; the film’s label claimed one.

Related Coverage