
The Fake Mia Goth Selfie Wore a Catalogue Slogan. Meta's Label Requirement Skips Stills.
The AI-generated Mia Goth selfie that OK! and People ran as real carries a slogan Amazon has listed since January 2023, which Luísa Sonza wore that June in a post fans read as a jab at her ex. Meta's AI-label requirement 'does not apply to images.'
Parallax Pincer
The selfie is framed at arm’s length in warm side light, with a bare face, one hand curled under the jaw and a white crew-neck tee that reads, in fat black serif capitals, MY EX IS MY BIGGEST FAN. The fan account @miagoth_ posted it on 8 October, two days after Mia Goth reportedly filed for divorce from Shia LaBeouf. Her representatives told The Verge the image was AI-generated, and The Verge says the account’s blue check likely caused the confusion. Two more things probably helped: the slogan was already in a catalogue, and Meta’s AI-label requirement does not cover still images.
OK! ran it as a “makeup-free selfie” showing “a cropped shirt with a pointed message aimed at an ex”. The Verge reports that People also treated it as authentic and that the post, set to Beyoncé’s “Single Ladies”, drew hundreds of thousands of likes. LADbible’s Facebook post said Goth “has pictured herself” in the shirt, and its graphic left the selfie out: a portrait of Goth, LaBeouf in a circle and the six words under a red quotation mark. As of 14 October, OK!’s own page returns “Page not found”, while the AOL copy runs uncorrected.
The slogan predates the fake. An Amazon print-on-demand seller has listed a “My Ex Is My Biggest Fan Funny T-Shirt” since 14 January 2023, the “Date First Available” on the page, in a soft, heavy Cooper Black-style serif that closely matches the fake’s lettering. That June, Brazilian singer Luísa Sonza wore the line on Instagram, in a post showing 962K likes. Her followers read it as a jab at her ex-husband, the comedian Whindersson Nunes, ISTOÉ reported. Sonza’s cropped top used plain sans-serif capitals, so the fake’s lettering matches the catalogue shirt rather than hers. Whether the model drew on that listing is unproven.
Slogan tees spoke for their wearers long before Instagram. London Museum dates Katharine Hamnett’s block-letter tees to 1983 and credits her with taking the look global, while noting that she “didn’t exactly invent the slogan t-shirt”; Westwood and McLaren’s 1977 “DESTROY” tee came first. Frieze recalls that in 1984 she “made headlines” by shaking hands with Margaret Thatcher in a T-shirt dress reading “58% Don’t Want Pershing”. “You can’t not read the slogans. You have no defences,” Hamnett told Frieze in 2019, adding: “What Cambridge Analytica et al. have been doing on social media, I was doing first!” The fake used the format to put words on a woman who never chose them.
Earlier AI outfit fakes leaned on spectacle. The pope’s white puffer, apparently first posted to a Midjourney subreddit in March 2023, gave itself away in a half-formed hand, cup and crucifix, The Verge noted. The maker of Katy Perry’s fake 2024 Met Gala gowns called the job “manual work, focusing on her body and face”, ABC News reported. The Goth fake needed a face and a slogan.
A plain white tee leaves a sceptic almost nothing to zoom in on.
The account called itself a fan page but carried a blue check and more than a million followers. The Verge ties the badge to Meta’s paid verification, which is open to accounts not run by the person in their pictures. Goth’s team had filed multiple complaints, The Verge reports, and the account kept posting counterfeit AI images. Goth’s representative Christine Tripicchio called it “disconcerting on a fundamental level” that the account qualified for a “blue check”. Meta spokesperson Alex Dziedzan said it was removed for impersonating a public figure.
The label gap is written down, and The Verge reported it: Meta’s rules include a carve-out for still images. Meta’s help page says it “may require an AI label when content has photorealistic video or realistic-sounding audio that was digitally created, modified or altered, including with AI”, then adds: “This requirement does not apply to images.” Among its examples of content needing no label is an “Image of a person riding a bull”. Images can still be labelled when Meta’s systems detect AI in them, but the page concedes that “Not all AI content contains the information needed to identify it.”
A second listing, under a different brand name, carries a first-available date of 8 October, the day of the post. The white “My Ex is My Biggest Fan Funny Sarcastic Cool Breakup Quote T-Shirt” wears the same black soft serif and is sold through Merch on Demand, where “each design is printed when you place your order”. Its listing sells “a deadpan brag about an unexpectedly loyal ex” and never names Goth. Nobody has to make that shirt until somebody buys it.
The outlets that ran this selfie took a verified fan page for the actress, and Meta’s page does not require a label for a still. This shirt carried no logo. If the next one carried a brand’s in an organic post, the same still-image rule would apply on the page’s wording. Meta adds that “Labelling and identifying AI content is different for ads.”