
Galeria Borrowed Against Its Stock From the Firm That Ran Its Closing Sales
Galeria's June rescue was a credit line secured on its merchandise from Gordon Brothers, the firm that once ran its closing sales. Loans of that kind typically value stock at what it would fetch in a clearance, which tied the chain's borrowing to shelves that falling sales were emptying. Galeria filed for insolvency on 2 October with the usual German wage bridge in doubt.
Admiral Neritus Vale
Galeria’s June rescue was a loan against the goods on its shelves, made by the firm that once ran its closing sales. On 30 September WirtschaftsWoche reported that the chain needed fresh money again, with some employees saying there was too little stock on hand. Two days later Galeria filed for insolvency at the Düsseldorf district court, its fourth filing since 2020. Those shelves were also the loan’s security. Loans secured on stock are typically sized by what the stock would fetch in a clearance, as the OCC’s guidance for US lenders puts it, so Galeria could borrow more only by filling shelves it could no longer afford to fill.
Creditors have paid for Galeria’s rescues before. Handelsblatt puts the claims they and the state waived in the three earlier cases at almost €5bn. This time, it reports, citing company circles, the case is a standard insolvency rather than self-administration. Frank Kebekus, custodian in the 2020 and 2022 cases, is named as provisional administrator in a staff memo seen by dpa. Handelsblatt describes him as the company’s proposal; the court makes the appointment.
The June loan paid out less than its headline. Gordon Brothers’ release, carried by ABL Advisor, announced “up to €160 million” in asset-based financing, which dpa reported was secured on Galeria’s merchandise. WirtschaftsWoche, as relayed by the Wetterauer Zeitung, put the first draw at about €130 million. In asset-based lending, “up to” often marks a borrowing base, so the gap may reflect what the collateral would support.
US bank regulators tell lenders to value retail stock as if the shop were closing. The OCC’s handbook on asset-based lending says such loans traditionally advance 80% of the stock’s net orderly liquidation value, “not cost or retail value”, and that a party independent of the credit transaction should set that value. Competition has pushed advance rates to 85% to 90%, and in some cases higher, the same handbook adds. Gordon Brothers sells valuation and lending together, using its “asset expertise to lend deeper into the collateral”, its website says. Galeria’s own advance rate has not been reported.
Gordon Brothers knows what this retailer’s goods fetch in a clearance. It ran the sell-off in Kaufhof and Karstadt stores before they closed, dpa noted. A 2021 German article on the firm, originally published by Business Insider and republished by WikiFX, says it sold off stock worth almost €300m for Galeria Karstadt Kaufhof as stores closed in 2020. The text counts those stores as 30 in one place and 40 in another. The figure is the value of the goods, not the proceeds, so it shows the scale of the exercise rather than the price. If the facility was sized on liquidation value, as such loans usually are, it financed Galeria’s shelves as clearance stock from the first day.
Galeria had already moved its own prices toward the clearance price. In May, with the loan still under negotiation, it took 25% off almost everything in every store, outside the regular sale seasons, retail-news.de reported. The same report read the discount as a sign of high inventories, with sales about €130m behind the year before, so the shelves were not yet empty. The OCC handbook describes lenders collecting markdown data as often as daily, to catch deteriorating collateral early. An appraiser who sees a whole range sold at a quarter off has a lower price to work from.
Under a line secured on stock, a retailer that buys less can borrow less. Galeria also had to cut its order volumes to keep its trade-credit insurance, the Lebensmittel Zeitung reported, and every order not placed was collateral never pledged. Handelsblatt reported sales about 15% down on the year in June, July and August, figures reprinted by Shoez that Galeria has not confirmed. Buying for Christmas anyway means paying for the range weeks before it sells, while the lender advances only part of its cost. By late September the decline had reportedly reached about 25%.
Galeria had pledged the one asset it could neither stop selling nor afford to replace.
The cash ran out before the stock did. After September’s wages, Galeria’s cash reportedly fell below a €20m floor agreed with its trade-credit insurers, WirtschaftsWoche reported, in an account carried by the Wetterauer Zeitung. A company spokesperson confirmed only that wages were paid on time. Handelsblatt reported the credit line as largely used up. If its ceiling fell with the stock, it would have met the insurers’ floor in September; no report gives Galeria’s borrowing base.
The usual German bridge out of this squeeze may be closed. Insolvency pay normally covers up to three months of wages under § 165 SGB III. The Essen court has not lifted its supervision of Galeria’s 2024 insolvency plan, dpa reported. In June a Federal Employment Agency spokesman said it could “with high probability” be assumed that insolvency pay could not be paid again (our translation), while adding that the earlier insolvency must no longer persist and that each case is assessed individually. The test comes from a Federal Social Court ruling of 6 December 2012 (B 11 AL 11/11 R): whether the employer’s insolvency continued without solvency regained. That case involved an unsupervised plan, and the court said supervision makes continuing insolvency “particularly clear” (our translation). Galeria’s managers told its roughly 12,000 staff that securing salaries for the coming months was their top priority.
The strongest objection is that no loan structure could have survived this fall in demand. With Creditreform still advising against lending to the chain in April, inFranken reported, Gordon Brothers arguably lent when nobody else would and bought Galeria a three-month reprieve. The cash gap also has a simpler explanation than collateral. Much of the first draw went straight out again: dpa reported that a loan from minority shareholder Bain Capital, put at about €80m, was to be repaid first, followed by overdue rent, with money also needed to order the autumn and winter range.
The objection holds if Galeria would have failed at the same moment and in the same way whatever secured its loan. Demand set the size of the loss; the security may have set its timing. A lender who advanced no more than the usual share of liquidation value stays covered whether the range sells at Christmas or clears in January, and has no need to fund Galeria’s shortfall. A lender who advanced deeper, as Gordon Brothers says it can, has less cover. The Wetterauer Zeitung’s account says talks with Gordon Brothers over more money were still open before the filing, and that a Galeria spokesperson expressly denied the firm had refused.
Kebekus’s first decisions will show which way Galeria’s stock goes. Once proceedings open, German insolvency law lets the administrator, not the secured lender, sell pledged goods the estate holds. Under § 170 InsO, the estate deducts its costs from the proceeds and the secured creditor is paid from the rest. If the agency confirms it will not pay, wages would have to come from that cost share, unless the lender agrees otherwise, and the firm that has run such clearances before holds the security. The rescue valued Galeria’s shelves as clearance stock; whether this Christmas proves that valuation right is a decision for the administrator.