
J.Crew Let SNL's Comedians Write the Fitting
Please Don't Destroy wrote J.Crew's suit film and turned the fitting into the punchline, while fit names and fabrics stayed in J.Crew's Instagram captions. Target handed Hacks co-creator Lucia Aniello the camera and swapped its 'weirdly hot' Santa for a plaid academy where the gifts sit among the props.
Parallax Pincer
A salesman in J.Crew’s new suit film asks a customer, “Just so I know, what size are you rocking down there?” The man answers, “What?”, and the reply comes back: “For the suit.” Once comedians hold the pen, the fitting becomes the punchline and the fit names move into the captions. Please Don’t Destroy, the trio of SNL cast member Ben Marshall and SNL writers Martin Herlihy and John Higgins, wrote J.Crew’s film with Brady Lees, and Herlihy directed. It runs 1 minute 46 seconds.
The fitting keeps going wrong. “Maybe we just go one size smaller,” someone offers, then asks, “Did you want to look like the Penguin?” before conceding, “I feel like we might have overshot it.” J.Crew’s three fits are named once, in passing: “Got them in the Kenmare, the Ludlow and the Crosby.” Elsewhere the subtitles run to “His head smells like coffee. Don’t smell his head” and “Stop eating macaroni and cheese.”
J.Crew’s Instagram posts keep selling cloth. The trio “audition our signature suit fits: Ludlow Slim, Crosby Classic and Kenmare Relaxed,” the caption says. Another post puts Higgins in “the Crosby Classic-fit suit in Italian wool flannel.” The film gets the jokes; the captions get the fabric.
Glossy’s briefing calls the trio “brand ambassadors” and files them beside fellow SNL faces Chloe Fineman, Sarah Sherman, Ashley Padilla and Bowen Yang.
The credit that changes this picture is “Written by.”
Even the fit names become material: “I’m a Kenmare rising, Ludlow moon and Crosby sun,” reads a post signed John Higgins. Glossy reports that the campaign was about demystifying men’s suiting, and the writers did it by making the salesmen the clowns. They nap (“I’m going to take a nap”), eat macaroni and cheese, and try to close early because “Today’s salsa day.”
J.Crew’s chief marketing officer, Julia Collier, said in a press statement, as Glossy quotes it, that the trio “made it entirely theirs, while showing how versatile and well-fitted our suits are.” The film delivers the first half of that sentence. Its last line, after the wordmark, is “Is now a bad time to discuss compensation?”
J.Crew’s lobby store supplied the occasion for an SNL fit joke once before. Tina Fey wrote SNL’s “Mom Jeans” parody, which aired on 10 May 2003, after buying what she called an unfortunate pair of jeans at “the J. Crew in the lobby” of 30 Rock. She told the story on SiriusXM’s Entertainment Weekly Radio in 2018, NBC Insider recounts. The high-waisted jeans outlived the sketch: NBC notes the term “is still shorthand for a certain denim cut.”
Twenty-three years on, the fitting-room joke has a client.
Target handed over the camera instead, with a campaign that launches in early November. Its fact sheet names “Hacks” co-creator Lucia Aniello as director and credits Target, Mythology and Hungry Man. Pat Regan, an Emmy-winning “Hacks” writer, plays the Last-Minute Gift Guidance Counselor. In the stills, the Chief Giftologist poses in a red plaid suit on a library ladder, and a painted portrait dresses Bullseye in a school V-neck and tie. Wrapped gifts are shelved among the books, a Pikachu plush sits in a teacher’s arms and a giant teddy bear wears a plaid scarf. The price list is not absent: the Head of Giftonomics pitches spending less, and Retail Dive says an earlier toy spot stresses Target Circle members getting up to 25% off.
Kris K., the hunky Santa of 2024 and 2025, won’t return, a Target spokesperson told Marketing Dive, Retail Dive reports. A shopper in the 2024 spot called him “weirdly hot,” and #TargetSanta drew over 70 million TikTok views, Marketing Dive reported last year. His 2025 return was “created alongside Mythology and Hungry Man,” the same team behind the academy, and that year’s “Step Into the Holidays” added the Get-Ready Yeti, the Gifting Mice and Buttons the Gingerbread across 10 spots. Kris K. was a joke that travelled as a hashtag. The academy swaps him for a faculty, nine spots and “The Academy Podcast.”
Retail Dive adds that the academy’s plaid gift-wrap decor will carry into stores, putting shoppers on the set, while Target pushes harder on TikTok and YouTube. Christina Lindley, a growth consultant with a comedy background, gave Glossy a test that Target’s academy also has to pass: “If you hire someone because they’re funny and then take all the personality out of the campaign, what was the point?” She added that “J. Crew putting Please Don’t Destroy in a suit shop makes sense. The clothes are part of the scene.” J.Crew split the work, leaving the film to the comedians and the fit names and fabrics to the captions.