
The RealReal Now Screens Agents and Keeps the 20-Minute Hold
An agent that kept re-holding The RealReal's one-of-a-kind listings exposed a 20-minute rule that its FAQ says nothing about renewing. Luke Friang told The Verge the bot defence now makes it much more difficult for agents to log in, add to cart and check out; The Verge reported no change to the hold.
Sir John Crabstone
On a site that sells each item once, the scarce good is the claim on it. The RealReal grants that claim for 20 minutes. When an agent kept renewing it, the company tightened its bot defence, and The Verge reported no change to the 20 minutes. Mia Sato found the gap for The Verge. She told Meta’s Muse to add the ten newest listings from one brand to her cart, then re-add each as its hold lapsed. It ran all day; she never meant to buy.
The RealReal’s buyer FAQ allows items to be held “so you can consider your purchase and continue shopping”. Then the reason: “because there is only one of each item on The RealReal, we cannot allow items to be held indefinitely.” The answer limits each hold. On the next one, it is silent.
The FAQ forbids an indefinite hold and says nothing to stop a fresh one every 20 minutes.
The RealReal also sells early access. First Look members pay $12 a month for “24-hour advance access to sales”. The FAQ lists no fee for a hold, and Sato’s test held ten listings all day.
After Sato’s story ran, chief technology officer Luke Friang told The Verge that the company had addressed the Muse case. Its bot defence, he said, now makes it much more difficult for all agents to log in, add items to cart and check out. The Verge’s headline said The RealReal won’t let agents “hog designer clothing”; its account of Friang’s email describes no change to the hold. Meta did not immediately respond to the fix.
The trick has a name. OWASP’s catalogue of automated threats lists it as Denial of Inventory: the “holding of items from a limited inventory or stock” that are never bought. Among its cross-references is “Improper Control of Interaction Frequency”, which reads like a flaw in the rule itself. A cap on renewals per account would need no opinion about who is clicking.
In a Fastly case study that predates Muse, a RealReal security engineer said: “If we have a customer buying a high-end item, we don’t want to lose the sale because of false positives.” Any screen with that priority lets through whatever looks like a customer.
Walmart took a different course on 21 October. Its website, Walmart said, “is built for people to browse, click and sign in themselves”, so it is building a Walmart Agent Gateway, starting with a beta for companies and developers. Agents that ignore its terms “will be blocked from Walmart’s site”. Both retailers screen agents; Walmart is also building them a door.
Meta told The Verge before the fix that Muse “is designed to always ask permission before buying” and applies “ethical browsing principles when asked to do things that a human could not - like buying all the tickets to an event”. A person could have made any one of Sato’s re-adds. The difference, as The Verge’s follow-up put it, is that a person has a limit on the time they will spend, and an agent “does not care”.