Policy & RegulationBriefing (Crabstone)
An auditor with a magnifying glass studies a phone showing a Temu product feed, beside a stamped action plan and a desk calendar turned to June 2027, while a customs officer weighs small parcels in the next room.

Temu Said Its Feed 'May Amplify' Illegal Goods. Brussels Wants the Analysis

The Commission has accepted Temu's plan to remedy May's €200m Digital Services Act fine, including an analysis of whether its recommender amplifies illegal goods, which its 2024 risk assessment said it 'may' do without saying how far. The Board for Digital Services found the plan short of detail, Temu is appealing the fine, and on the plan's own timetable the audit reports by about June 2027, a year into the EU's new parcel charges.

Sir John Crabstone

Temu’s recommender is now part of the remedy for its €200m fine. On 26 October the Commission accepted the plan Temu filed after May’s decision under the Digital Services Act. Among five measures, Temu will analyse whether its recommender systems “may amplify the spread of illegal goods”.

The “may” echoes Temu’s own. Its 2024 risk assessment, quoted in the May decision, said its recommender “may amplify the promotion” of prohibited products and “may prioritise / surface on consumers’ feeds products which infringe IP”. The Commission found no analysis of “how or to what extent such amplification occurs in practice”. Temu named the tendency without weighing it.

Its risk rating leaned on a borrowed number. Temu called the residual likelihood of risk “low” using “a single sector-wide benchmark of 4%”, the decision records. That figure came from a March 2021 Civic Consulting study of dangerous products, whose data predate Temu’s arrival in the EU; the Commission called it an inappropriate benchmark.

Temu was fined €200m for a poor essay; the rest of its sentence is to write a better one.

The five measures are all inquiries. Temu must assess its own service with “up-to-date information”, test whether its safeguards work and explain how gaps in moderation affect recommended products. It must also measure its recommender’s effect with “reliable metrics” and examine how traders may exploit its features. None of the five orders a change to the feed; the breach lay in the assessment.

The Board for Digital Services, where national regulators sit, gave its opinion on 24 September. It found the changes “partially adequate” but said the plan “lacked sufficient level of detail” to judge whether it cured the breach. The Commission accepted it all the same, having “clarified key requirements” and promised to “closely supervise” the points the Board found inadequately explained.

Euronews, reporting with AFP, headlined the approval “Temu falls into line”. It quoted Temu welcoming the plan as showing “commitment to investing in robust compliance infrastructure”, and did not mention the Board.

Temu is remedying a breach whose fine it is contesting. The two companies fined, PDD Holdings and Whaleco Technology, have appealed, MLex reported in August, and the fine was part of a wider EU probe that continues. Here, falling into line includes a court challenge.

Temu has four months to implement the plan, including an interim risk assessment covering the six months to 30 November. An independent audit follows, reporting within four months of implementation. No date is published for the audited answer; on that timetable it arrives by about the end of June 2027.

Those six months contain both of the EU’s new parcel charges. The Commission’s customs guidance describes a €3 duty, applied since 1 July to distance-sale consignments of up to €150 and charged per declaration line. The same guidance expects a €2 handling fee per item from 1 November.

Since 1 November, distance-sale declarations must carry product identifiers, including a merchant product identifier “such as the reference number on the product page”. When one product fails a check, customs can extend the result to every product “presenting a similar risk”, even on other platforms.

The border can now trace a failed charger to its listing. Whether Temu’s feed pushed that listing further is the question its own wording left open.