
Reddit's Review Test Is the One Every Shill Is Paid to Pass
Reddit's new review pages show prices beside verdicts built from comments that appear to describe personal experience, which is what paid shills write, and volunteer moderators are part of the fraud check. For clothing, a tally of positive, mixed and negative may not tell disagreement from different bodies.
Sir John Crabstone
A comment counts towards a Reddit review only if it “appears to describe personal experience with a product”. Reddit’s product marketing team, posting as u/brandy_mcstyle, gave moderators that definition on 10 November. Sounding like experience is the paid shill’s whole trade, and Reddit now shows prices on the same pages as the verdicts. Volunteer moderators are part of its fraud check, and many are objecting.
The pages are rolling out to US users with about 10,000 products in four categories, Fashion & Apparel among them. An AI summary headed “what people are saying” tops a tally of positive, mixed and negative comments, followed by common likes and dislikes. Many reviews carry prices and purchase links “where supplied by brand and retailer catalogs”.
Reddit insists the verdicts are not for sale. Advertisers “cannot pay to have their products included or excluded”, the same account told moderators, and Reddit “does not earn commission”. Both claims may hold, and neither touches the astroturfer, who pays a writer, not Reddit.
In February, TechCrunch reported, an earlier carousel test matched community recommendations “with products from some of the company’s shopping and advertising partners”. The November pages cite only “brand and retailer catalogs”. The crowd supplies the verdict; someone else supplies the price.
Beyond its automated filters, Reddit names three layers of defence: its Safety team, volunteer moderators and users’ votes. Two of the three are unpaid. The votes need guarding themselves: in a July post on spam, Reddit said it was revoking nearly two million inauthentic votes a day, and blocking 23 million spam views.
CNET reports that Reddit says highlighted product mentions will appear in threads “regardless of a group’s rules preventing the promotion of products”. Many moderators believe real opinions will be hard to tell from advertising, and the quarrel turns on whether such a link is an ad. Reddit’s reply is that it is “not an ad. Rather, it’s a shortcut”, though CNET adds that Reddit is also testing ads in search results, which could reach people who click a product name without paying for placement in Reviews.
For Reviews, Reddit says it also excludes labelled bots and watches for spikes. A books-community moderator named the gap: bad-faith users claim to have used the product, and “they’re just lying about it.” The marketer replied, “Yes, that’s fair,” and said the team would “see what additional measures we can implement”. The pages show no usernames for now, though clicking a comment opens the original discussion, so the shopper meets the testimony one click before the witness.
Clothing brings a difficulty no spam filter touches. Reddit’s own People’s Fashion Index, published on 5 November, says “off-the-rack fit and tailoring for non-standard body types” accounts for 88% of views to r/malefashionadvice, though it does not disclose its method. Fit advice is conditional: size up if you are broad, not if you are slight.
Reddit lists themes such as comfort and durability “where available” and does not say whether fit is among them. If it is not, a tally may fold conditional advice into a single verdict; that is a risk, not an observed result.
On a blazer, a mixed verdict could mean the reviewers disagreed, or only that their shoulders did.
TechCrunch says the feature could make Reddit more of a research destination, and a larger target for fake reviews. Reddit’s defences, it reports, are its rules, anti-spam measures and community moderators. In the thread, a member of Reddit’s Reviews Council praised the product team’s dedication to keeping reviews authentic.
One commenter suggested ignoring accounts less than a month old. The marketer called it a great idea that the team was discussing. Versions of the feature have been in testing since February, with a council of moderators advising.