Policy & RegulationBriefing (Crabstone)
A trader feeds equal bundles of banknotes tagged £89,000 into four tills labelled Amazon, eBay, Etsy and OnBuy, while a tax inspector checks a single till against a £90,000 yardstick.

£89,000 on Each of Four Marketplaces, and None Would Have to Collect the VAT

Britain is expected to make Amazon, eBay and Temu collect VAT for business sellers above £90,000, and the government's lead proposal counts that line one platform at a time. Its own consultation lists spreading sales across marketplaces as evasion and concedes that much non-compliance would escape; the Budget on 28 October will settle the count.

Sir John Crabstone

John Healey’s first Budget, on 28 October, is expected to make Amazon, eBay and Temu collect the VAT owed by businesses that sell through them. The Times reported on 13 October that the Budget will include the plan, and that the duty will cover sellers with “an annual turnover of more than £90,000”. Whether that sum belongs to a trader or to a trader’s sales on one marketplace decides whom the reform can catch. Critics wanted the line lower; ministers refused, the paper says, after lobbying by the Federation of Small Businesses.

The figure is borrowed. Since April 2024, £90,000 has been the VAT registration threshold, measured against a business’s taxable turnover over twelve months. It does not ask how many tills took the money. A threshold is a promise to look away below a certain sum; the only question is whose.

The marketplace version would look at less. The June consultation from HMRC and the Treasury proposes extending to UK businesses the duty marketplaces have carried for overseas sellers since 2021. Its “lead proposal” brings in only those “with total sales on individual platforms” above £90,000. Among its three patterns of evasion is the UK business that spreads sales across several marketplaces “to appear under the VAT threshold”, and it concedes that “a significant amount of VAT non-compliance” would escape a £90,000 line. Its own example of that gap is a seller splitting sales across accounts on one platform; the cross-marketplace case is our reading, though the paper does say that similar businesses fare differently depending on “their balance of sales between different online marketplaces”.

Take a trader who splits £356,000 evenly across Amazon, eBay, Etsy and OnBuy: each marketplace sees £89,000 and a small trader, and none sees the large one.

That trader must still register for VAT; the consultation says a marketplace threshold would not remove the obligation once total turnover passes £90,000. What escapes is collection at the till. Finding the trader falls to HMRC, as it does now.

Nothing is settled until the Budget speech. Ecommerce News Europe, crediting The Times, reports that the government is weighing £90,000 “in annual sales per platform”, and that critics fear sellers will spread sales across accounts or platforms. The Times copy itself says turnover. The two wordings differ on the denominator, and the denominator is the policy.

Others want the line gone. Andrew Goodacre, chief executive of the British Independent Retailers Association, would scrap the threshold altogether, Talking Retail reports: “All sales should incur VAT, full stop.” In the magazine’s summary, his association warns that sellers will exploit the carve-outs and leave the revenue well below the expected £1bn. A lower line helps only so far; a per-platform count multiplies with every marketplace a trader joins.

The other proposed carve-out, for second-hand goods, lands on clothing. People clearing wardrobes are outside the proposal anyway; the question concerns dealers, who may pay VAT only on their margin, under a scheme marketplaces cannot use. The government’s options are to leave a business’s second-hand sales out or to tax the full price of every coat it resells. It has already asked what risks remain “around misrepresentation of goods as second-hand”. On a rail of clothes, we suspect, a swing tag and the seller’s word are often all that separate new from old.

We noted in September that no public estimate has replaced the 2021 figure for what British retail runs through Amazon’s sellers. Under the lead proposal, four marketplaces would each count one small trader, and none would add the four sums together. Someone must, and the reform leaves that someone as HMRC.

Related Coverage