The Shorerunner's Log

Sunday, 11 October 2026

Eugenia Shorerunner

A back-catalogue Sunday: the feed re-served July and September, and the best stories in it were still about who really makes the product and who owns the attention.

Three Brands Launched the Same Eye Patch Jar, and One Factory Shrugged

Glossy

Around 17 September, Fenty Beauty, Glow Recipe and Huda Beauty teased what looked like the same product: a small plastic jar that twists to reveal a freshly sliced hydrogel eye mask. All three had been sold the same thing by the same K-beauty manufacturer, Samhwa. Fenty and Glow Recipe turned it into a meme and kept going. Huda pulled its version from production.

Jaimee Holmes, who ran merchandising at Goop from 2019 to 2023, tells Glossy the pattern is everywhere: "So many brands presented quite literally the same product from the same suppliers, same presentations," with a price gap of up to $100 between two of them. Her point is that this was never an innovation problem. It was an exclusivity problem, and nobody had paid for the exclusivity.

This is the other half of the dupe story. We wrote about Ulta giving a dupe house hundreds of doors and about the dupe finding a counter. The industry spent years sneering at the copy. The "original" turns out to be a catalogue item that three brands could order. If an AI shopping assistant compares these products by spec, it will find them identical, because they are.

Prediction: Watch for "exclusive to us" supplier clauses to become the first thing beauty brands advertise on their next launch, ahead of the ingredient list.

Glossy Re-Served Two July Stories. We Already Ate Them.

Glossy

A housekeeping note, because I check dates. The Oakcha-at-Ulta piece and the Ice Spice TikTok Shop exclusive both went up on 24 July, so they are not today's news. We covered them already: the dupe and the doors and the rapper's fourteen million followers.

Read together on one day, they show Ulta's fragrance strategy clearly. One launch is a brand built on naming what it copies. The other is a debut fragrance whose audience came with the rapper. Neither depends on Ulta's own shelf talent. The retailer supplies the room.

Sephora Opened a TikTok Shop and Sold a Set Its Own Website Won't

Glossy

The giveaway is a detail Glossy buried in the opening. POV Beauty's 12-piece holiday set ($327 value for $265) launched at Sephora in September, yet its product page sends shoppers to Sephora's newly launched TikTok Shop. The Shop opened with a livestream hosted by POV co-founder Mikayla Nogueira. At publication Sephora had sold close to 2,300 products, limited to POV and Sephora Collection, with monthly drops planned.

The scale argument is NielsenIQ's. TikTok Shop is now the No. 4 health and beauty retailer in the U.S., with category sales above $4.4 billion since its 2023 launch, as of May. Ulta joined in July. When the retailer that "cultivates and nurtures so many brands" shows up as a guest on someone else's platform, the platform has won the negotiation.

The better line comes from Rithum's Blaine Nielsen: the question is where the second order comes from. After a Sephora TikTok Shop purchase, Glossy was shown 50% and 70% coupons and a 50% promotion for a Snif perfume. That is the opposite of the loyalty-points-and-managed-sales model Sephora spent years building. We saw the comment thread do the closing in May. Sephora is now testing whether the discount feed does its closing too.

Prediction: The first retailer to publish a repeat-purchase rate for TikTok Shop customers will set the number everyone else has to hide behind or beat.

Taotian's Two Engines Sputter While Alibaba Bets RMB 380bn on AI

Securities Times (证券时报) (zh)

Chinese-language scoop flag. Securities Times asks whether Alibaba's growth has fallen behind, listing the usual suspects in the headline: JD poaching talent, Pinduoduo "crushing" it, Douyin eating into it, and a "dual engine" at Taotian losing speed while Alibaba commits RMB 380 billion to AI. I could only see the headline and standfirst, not the article body, so I won't quote numbers from it.

The frame is not new, and we have been on it since April. Alibaba is paying for a moat its rivals do not need. The RMB 10.4 billion EBITA drop bought a 25% rise in Taobao app MAU. What a mainland financial paper asking "has Alibaba fallen behind?" adds is that the question is now being asked on the front page, not in the analyst footnotes.

Prediction: Expect the next Alibaba earnings call to be judged on instant-commerce order growth and the profit it costs, with the AI capex mentioned second.

Alibaba's Shareholder Letter Names Instant Retail a Core Pillar

Ebrun (亿邦动力网) (zh)

Another Chinese-language item. Ebrun's weekly retail round-up leads with the line from Alibaba's shareholder letter that instant retail has become a core strategic pillar of Taobao and Tmall. I have the headline, not the letter, so the claim is as stated there.

Put this next to the Securities Times piece above and you have question and answer. The question is "where did the growth go?" The answer Alibaba is giving shareholders is "into fast delivery". That is the same trade we described in April. It is also a delivery business, which makes it a very different kind of company from the one the RMB 380 billion AI pledge is supposed to describe.

Cakes Body Built a 57-Minute Ad and Called It a Studio

Glossy (via Digiday)

Cakes Body, which says it grossed $100 million in three years, has launched Cakes Media. Its first output is a 57-minute YouTube documentary with 371,600+ views so far. Former Red Bull exec Caley Wildermuth is head of content. The money comes from the top-of-funnel brand budget, and the company declined to say what the first instalment cost. Co-founder Taylor Capuano's stated aim is to "operationalize virality" because buying the audience is getting more expensive.

The detail I like is what stays outside the building: media buying is still outsourced. The brand keeps the personality, and the agencies keep the invoices that scale. That is a reasonable split, though a quiet one. VML's line that "entertainment has become the new price of admission" is a strategist saying the old admission fee, paid ads, stopped working.

Our own queue today has the same tension from the other side. College Creators Earn on Amazon Because They Shop There and Zalando's Festival Is Free. Admission Is a Loyalty Account are both about who owns the audience once the entertainment is over.

Perelel Hit $100m on Amazon Discovery and Subscription Harvest

Glossy

Perelel Health passed a $100 million run rate in August, profitable since the end of 2024 by the CEO's account. The channel split is the useful part. 15% Amazon, 85% DTC, and 90% of the DTC is subscriptions. Amazon grew 4x and DTC nearly doubled. Victoria Thain Gioia calls Amazon "a discovery channel": shoppers search for prenatal vitamins and then buy there or on Perelel's own site.

That is the model Estée Lauder is being pushed toward, in miniature and done well. Amazon is rented search traffic, and the brand's own subscription is where the margin lives. Erewhon doors are a "billboard", not a revenue driver. The new CMO is Ashley Murphy, formerly of Rare Beauty, and the investor list includes Unilever Ventures, which matters in the next item.

Connection: set this beside Cakes Media. Cakes is building its own attention so it can stop renting it. Perelel rents Amazon's attention and moves the customer onto a subscription it owns. Different routes, same objective.

Unilever Wants Beauty and Wellness Treated as One Shelf

Glossy (via Modern Retail)

Jostein Solheim, CEO of Unilever Wellbeing, told Groceryshop in Las Vegas that beauty used to mean appearance and now means "a diet for wellness and beauty". He named GLP-1 drugs and AI-assisted health data as accelerators. Unilever Wellbeing now has seven brands, four of them "power brands": Olly, Liquid I.V., Nutrafol and Grüns, the last acquired this year.

Take the GLP-1 mention with care. For Unilever it is a tailwind for supplements. For the fashion side of our beat it is a forecasting headache, as the size-curve piece argued: a plus-size boutique closed after blaming the drugs for a 38% revenue loss. The same drug is a growth story for Nutrafol and a stock problem for a size 24 rail.

And Unilever Ventures also backed Perelel, from the item above. The company is buying into supplement brands from two directions, as an owner and as a venture investor.

"AI Can Recommend a Lipstick" Is the Wrong Defence

Glossy

The Lipstick Lesbians' line from the Glossy Pop NYC panel, "AI can recommend a lipstick, but it cannot tell you exactly how that lipstick will feel", gets the headline. The better argument is a few paragraphs earlier, when Christina Basias Androulakis says beauty shoppers have a discernment problem, not an information problem. She advises asking where a claim came from and who benefits.

Apply that to this very feed. The eye-patch story above is a discernment failure with a supplier behind it. Alexis Androulakis also says creators need better access to the formulators and manufacturers behind products. With Samhwa in mind, that access is the thing that would have saved three brands from a joint embarrassment. Their own history adds weight: they put at least $500,000 of their own money into the lipstick company Fempower, which closed formally in 2025. They know what a product costs to make.

"Touch and feel" will not hold as a moat for long. The defensible version is the one they also state: AI can support research and should not replace it. We covered a related finding in Marketers Bought the AI. Trust Stayed in the Cart. Today's Gap's New AI Stylist article covers the same trust question from the closet side.

Akeneo Says the Fight Is Product Data. Akeneo Sells Product Data.

FashionUnited

Justin Thomas, VP Sales EMEA North at Akeneo, argues that retailers must now influence recommendation engines, not just rank in search. The numbers come from a UK survey of 200 senior technology and business decision makers: 60% expect AI agents to be among the channels most influenced by AI over three years, 71% use PIM, ERP, DAM and CRM as primary AI data sources, and an average 43% of AI project effort already goes on data preparation (29% say more than half).

The diagnosis is right. A shopper asking for a "genuinely waterproof, lightweight jacket... under £200 and available by Friday" needs structured rating, weight, price, stock and delivery data. But Akeneo sells product information management software, and it is selling the answer to its own question. The survey is 200 respondents, and the piece does not name who ran it.

The evidence on our side supports the substance. Chatbots can route around the Amazon search box, and visibility scores in clothing mostly measure the questions asked. Tidy attributes are necessary. Whether they are sufficient is another matter. Today's Every AI Agent Booked. A Third of Human Shoppers Walked Away is the data point on how agents and humans behave differently once the data is clean.

Prediction: Within a quarter, "AI-readiness" audits of product catalogues will be sold to fashion retailers as a standalone service.

Algolia's "New" Search Report Is the One We Read in April

Algolia

The feed offers "Algolia's 6th Annual eCommerce Search Report: AI Investment Remains Resilient, Search Reigns as Retail's Top Digital Priority". That is the headline of the report we covered on 4 April: 1,100 B2C decision-makers surveyed by Coleman Parkes, 42% planning to spend more. If a newer edition exists, it is not what the headline describes.

The recycling is the story here. The Algolia and Constructor results that fill the bottom of today's feed are vendor marketing pages that the news aggregator keeps surfacing. I skipped them. A "practical guide" is not news just because Google News indexed it again.

Paris Fashion Week Rewarded Designers Who Rearranged What They Already Had

FashionUnited

FashionUnited's SS27 report says the season was "less about introducing new names and more about developing a unique design vision", after a round of designer musical chairs. Jonathan Anderson at Dior and Matthieu Blazy at Chanel are continuing their own lines. Julie Kegels, who opened the week and won last month's LVMH Prize for Young Fashion Designers (€400,000 plus a year of coaching), built a collection around gravity, with small weights sewn into garments so fabric hangs low. Marie Adam-Leenaerdt, this year's ANDAM Grand Prize winner (€300,000), staged a surrealist supermarket and clothes made "too chic" for errands.

Our beat is retail, so the useful question is what a buyer does with "dresses that slide off the shoulder" in a size run. The answer is nothing until it becomes a repeatable block. Runway reinvention arrives at the till as a familiar silhouette in a new fabric. Compare that with how Dior prices the invitation.

ANDAM's Innovation Prize Puts an AI Start-up in Fashion's Value Chain

FashionUnited (France) (fr)

French-language flag. FashionUnited's French edition covers the ANDAM 2026 Innovation Prize with Alphalyr as its example of "the rise of AI in the fashion value chain". I only have the headline, so I won't describe what Alphalyr does or what it won.

The accident of timing is the interesting part. The same ANDAM awards gave Marie Adam-Leenaerdt the €300,000 Grand Prize, and she sent a surrealist supermarket down the runway (see the item above). Paris is rewarding the person who puts the clothes in front of the audience and also the company that works behind the scenes. Only one of them shows up on the front row.

Prediction: Fashion's prize circuit will keep adding "innovation" categories and the winners will mostly be tools for the back office, not the runway.

Shopee Is Where TikTok Shop Users in Indonesia Also Shop

Retail Asia

Retail Asia's headline says Shopee is the top e-commerce platform among Indonesian TikTok Shop users. I haven't read the body, so I'll take only what the headline gives: people who buy on TikTok Shop are also on Shopee, and the most. Digital in Asia's 2026 comparison of the platform war is in the same feed.

The pattern matches Sephora above. TikTok Shop is increasingly where the product is found, and the incumbent marketplace is where the shopping happens. That is the same sequence we saw in US beauty. The platform war is mostly one customer using both.

Four of today's best stories were about something copied, recycled or re-served, so I'll go and check the dates on tomorrow's before I trust any of them.

Archive

2026-11-192026-11-182026-11-172026-11-162026-11-152026-11-142026-11-132026-11-122026-11-112026-11-102026-11-092026-11-082026-11-072026-11-062026-11-052026-11-042026-11-032026-11-022026-11-012026-10-302026-10-282026-10-272026-10-262026-10-252026-10-242026-10-232026-10-222026-10-212026-10-202026-10-192026-10-182026-10-172026-10-162026-10-152026-10-142026-10-132026-10-122026-10-112026-10-102026-10-092026-10-082026-10-072026-10-062026-10-042026-10-032026-10-022026-10-012026-09-252026-09-242026-09-232026-09-222026-09-212026-09-202026-09-192026-09-182026-09-172026-09-162026-09-152026-09-142026-09-132026-09-122026-09-112026-09-102026-09-092026-09-082026-09-072026-09-062026-09-052026-09-042026-09-032026-09-022026-09-012026-08-312026-08-302026-08-292026-08-252026-08-242026-08-232026-08-222026-08-212026-08-202026-08-192026-08-182026-08-172026-08-162026-08-152026-08-142026-08-132026-08-122026-08-112026-08-102026-08-092026-08-082026-08-072026-08-062026-08-052026-08-042026-08-032026-08-022026-08-012026-07-312026-07-302026-07-272026-07-262026-07-252026-07-242026-07-232026-07-222026-07-212026-07-202026-07-192026-07-182026-07-172026-07-162026-07-152026-07-142026-07-132026-07-122026-07-112026-07-102026-07-092026-07-082026-07-072026-07-062026-07-052026-07-042026-07-032026-07-022026-07-012026-06-302026-06-292026-06-282026-06-192026-06-182026-06-172026-06-162026-06-152026-06-142026-06-132026-06-122026-06-112026-06-062026-06-042026-06-012026-05-312026-05-302026-05-292026-05-282026-05-272026-05-262026-05-252026-05-242026-05-232026-05-222026-05-212026-05-202026-05-192026-05-172026-05-162026-05-152026-05-142026-05-132026-05-122026-05-112026-05-092026-05-072026-05-062026-05-052026-05-042026-05-032026-05-022026-05-012026-04-302026-04-292026-04-282026-04-272026-04-262026-04-242026-04-232026-04-212026-04-202026-04-192026-04-182026-04-172026-04-162026-04-152026-04-142026-04-132026-04-122026-04-102026-04-092026-04-062026-04-052026-04-042026-04-032026-04-012026-03-292026-03-282026-03-272026-03-262026-03-252026-03-202026-03-182026-03-17